No GiveWell-equivalent evaluator for UK domestic causes

openclaimed ·shipped ·
outcome →own your town
What is missing

London hosts world-class effective-giving infrastructure, Founders Pledge, Longview Philanthropy, Giving What We Can and an Open Philanthropy presence, and it channels UK tech wealth almost entirely to global health and catastrophic-risk causes. No organisation publishes rigorous, public cost-effectiveness rankings for UK domestic charities and civic interventions. NPC offers bespoke consultancy, small efforts like SoGive lack scale, and donors seeking evidence-ranked domestic options have nowhere authoritative to look.

Why it matters

CAF shows wealthy Britons cite lack of confidence in impact as a barrier to giving. A trusted domestic evaluator would raise giving volumes and steer them towards the systematically unfunded categories this map documents, at a cost trivial relative to the funds influenced.

What would fill it

An independent UK-domestic evaluator at £2-3m a year publishing open cost-effectiveness assessments of UK charities and civic interventions, paired with a pooled UK effective giving fund: a natural first grant for Founders Pledge members or the Office for the Impact Economy to catalyse.

// Build now: First artefact: open cost-effectiveness rankings of UK domestic charities from public accounts and evaluations, plus a pooled effective-giving fund.

Why urgency 0

A trusted domestic evaluator would raise giving and steer it to unfunded fields cheaply, and no dated trigger creates urgency, so it can be built opportunistically.

claims & evidence · 3

// each factual claim in this entry, its source, and when it was last checked. Unresolved attributions are flagged rather than hidden. Challenge any of them on the thread below.

  • 152.1verifiedchecked 2026-07-07
    London hosts world-class effective-giving infrastructure, including Founders Pledge, Longview Philanthropy and Giving What We Can, channelling UK tech wealth almost entirely to global health and catastrophic-risk causes.
    The organisations' own cause-area statements establish the international weighting.
  • 152.2verifiedchecked 2026-07-07
    No organisation publishes rigorous, public cost-effectiveness rankings for UK domestic charities; NPC offers bespoke consultancy and SoGive lacks scale.
    Absence claim. Checked NPC's product list, SoGive's coverage, the Charity Commission register and giving platforms; nothing publishes GiveWell-style domestic rankings.
  • 152.3verifiedchecked 2026-07-07
    CAF's research shows wealthy Britons cite lack of confidence in impact as a barrier to giving.
ATTEMPTS · 0 ACTIVEnon-exclusive
// nobody on this yet: be first
// no account: your claim posts publicly and lands in the thread below
THREAD · 0 POSTSreplies post via github, in publicopen on github ↗
// quiet so far. the dossier is the first post: reply below or take the gap.

More in Civic society

Candidate entry from the July 2026 research pass, not yet validated by practitioner interviews. Added 2026-07-07 · last verified 2026-07-07 · review by 2027-01-07. Facts citing live processes (bills, consultations, contracts) decay quickly; re-verify against sources before acting.